Skip to main content
Snarkflix
← Browse all reviews
Obsession (2025) — review header image

Obsession (2025) review

Great

SnarkAI score, out of 100

Merlin approves.

Content warningSexual violence · Suicide and self-harm · Animal death · Graphic violenceThis review describes these in detail. Show the reviewHide the review

An indie film with a budget of just $750,000 and a worldwide box office return of $520 million, this movie has made breakout stars of Michael Johnston and Inde Navarrette. But is it any good?

Its premise, a "One Wish Willow" (a magic spell bound in a stick), is often described as a Monkey's Paw, mostly by those unwilling to hold men responsible for their actions. It's not a Monkey's Paw, it's straight-up wish fulfilment. He doesn't get an ironic twist on his wish; he gets exactly what he wishes for. There's no misinterpretation or malevolence. "Bear" is just a monster who doesn't really care about Nikki as a person, only as an object he wants. He's a common, casual monster perhaps, one we see every day, one who thinks little, if at all, of women's personhood, but a monster nonetheless. We know this for a fact because his friend Ian, the frat boy, wishes for a billion dollars. It falls from the ceiling as they watch. No evil consequence. No Monkey's Paw. Just exactly what he asked for. It's the film underscoring the horror of Bear's wish. Even the Reddit threads he reads at one point say the same. You get your wish.

We meet our villain, Bear, immediately. Bear's a loser. Sat in a diner, he's in beige, his hair scruffy and his face unshaven. He narrates a meandering, whiny, self-indulgent confession to a girl, but she's a waitress; he's practising what he'll tell Nikki. Ian, his frat-boy friend (Fratboy from here on), is trying to get him to be less cringe. Quite why you'd ever listen to a guy in a backwards baseball cap on how to talk to women, I don't know. The waitress says it's cute and she likes it. He ignores her telling him that. It becomes a pattern: Bear repeatedly ignores women telling him things.

He goes to a hippy store to buy a crystal necklace for Nikki for some reason, but instead buys the One Wish Willow. They're under ten dollars and sold in novelty boxes straight from the 50s. He gets a very, very clear warning from the person selling it that people come back complaining, saying they wish they were dead. He ignores this.

In one of the few emotionally honest scenes in the film, Bear's devastated to find his cat has got into his open pill bottles and died. (We'll call these Chekhov's Pills, by the way.) But he's not so devastated that he won't head out to see Nikki when she calls. His total emotional unavailability is once more on show as he doesn't mention his cat's died until he can use it to manipulate Nikki.

Early on, Nikki tries to set Bear up with Sarah. He hears the bit where she says "If I have a crush on a guy, no one knows", but ignores her trying to set him up with a different woman. He chickens out twice in telling her. Then he negs her and she hates it. She specifically says, "Do you like me? Now's the time to say something." He chickens out again, in fact implicitly denying it, and she's relieved.

His solution to all the above is to spiritually rape Nikki. His wish is extreme: he wishes "she loves [him] more than anyone in the fucking world". It's a disgusting theft of her autonomy and cements Bear solidly as the villain of this film.

She comes out from the house, clearly out of it. She's suddenly aware she's acting weird. It's unhinged but Bear's enjoying it, laughing, smiling. She's freaked out, but he's thriving on the attention. She gets confused about whose cat died, and then tells him her father's dying.

She gets him to take her from her place to his, gets into his bed and takes her shirt off. He knows she's acting oddly, he knows she's perhaps drunk, perhaps something else, and he's not stopping. She kisses him and he's super into taking advantage. When she screams he says, "I thought I did something you didn't like." So on some level he understands the concept of consent. This is pretty much the only indication in the film that he does.

Visually the film is incredible. There's a really great scene where she's on his doorstep, and just a catchlight in her eyes can be seen, her face in shadow. It's creepy and intimidating and erotic all at the same time. It gives the impression something is looking out of her eyes. In another beautifully shot scene she stands in a dark corner, her pale face and teeth showing. It's a callback to any number of horror films with a vengeful female ghost.

The sound design is great. We get a swelling of happy-couple music when Bear and Nikki get together, but with a discordant note running through it all, slowly becoming more prominent as we see a number of scenes of Bear raping Nikki, as she's entirely unable to consent. The end of the film plays 50s-style romance music over screaming. It's deliberately jarring.

The acting from the four leads is fantastic. Bear and Nikki in particular make you forget how few people are actually in this film. When Bear finally calls her out for lying about her father's cancer, we get the viral "No, no, no" scene, which is powerful and disturbing. She asks why it matters if her father has cancer or not. "Doesn't matter to me," he says, and it cuts to him vigorously thrusting into her on the bed as she stares vacantly into space, making noises that could perhaps be considered a moan if you'd never heard one before.

Whilst Nikki's creeping and her reactions are concerning, in a lot of ways she's showing an extreme version of how sexual abuse survivors behave. She's trying to keep him happy and calm, changing her story so as not to upset him, over-expressing her love for him. Swinging between regret and obsession. It's chilling how the film makes her seem to be the problem.

The ongoing fact that he's claiming he loves her whilst she does entirely strange things and behaves nothing like the Nikki he claimed to be in love with puts the lie to everything he says.

She slowly goes further and further off the rails as the film continues. She's taped the entire door shut to keep him home. She stands, waiting for him when he leaves. She pisses herself almost immediately. When he does finally get home, she's covered in vomit and waste. She's been stood, unmoving, watching for him to come home. The meat in the lunchbox is his cat. Perhaps because it's the only way she can resist, perhaps because it's the only meat available without going out, which she can't do without him.

Even Fratboy thinks it's clear Bear's taking advantage of Nikki by this point in the film. If a frat guy thinks you're being rapey, maybe listen. They are experts.

At one point, Bear calls the One Wish Willow helpline. He's not even trying to get the wish removed, only "changed a bit". He still wants her, and wants her to want him; he just wants to dial back her obsession so she's not feeding him his dead cat. He finds out two things: the one way to end the wish is to die, and the guy on the phone can put the screaming soul of Nikki on the line. Bear hangs up.

Maybe the most on-the-nose moment is at a party. Nikki reads out a disturbing Hansel and Gretel incest fic as part of the dare game. It's a clear cry for help, the story touching on the willow branch and calling back to Nikki seeing Bear as her little brother. Things get increasingly uncomfortable as the game continues until she screams "It's not me" and glasses herself in the face. Bear sits there unmoved. His sex toy has embarrassed him. It's Fratboy who insists on taking her to the hospital.

He screams at her and she flinches, demanding to know why she can't just be Nikki. We know by now he never really knew who Nikki was, and even now he's trying to force her to be the version of Nikki who wants him. He knows now she isn't, but he's still trying to take advantage for as long as he can.

Whispering in her sleep, the real Nikki begs him to kill her. Instead Bear asks, "What would be so bad about being with me?" After all this time, Bear still won't listen to what women tell him.

In the climax, Bear's chilling in the car, flirting with Sarah, until Nikki smashes the window and slams Sarah's face into a brick, over and over again, with shocking violence. She points out, "Don't forget you wanted this." "This is all your fault, Sarah is your fault, you wished for this." He's still not listening. It can't get much clearer. He helps her hide the body because he's a coward.

He tries to pass responsibility to the One Wish Willow store owner. He then tries to get Ian to do a cancellation wish, which fails as Ian wishes for money. When Nikki kills Ian, Bear finally goes and takes his Chekhov's Pills, but it's impossible at this stage to see this as doing it to free Nikki. It can only be read as doing it because he's got two of his best friends killed, the woman he was molesting is screaming any time she remembers herself, and there is no good way out for him. So he takes the easy way out: not even with the gun he took from Nikki, as he can't bring himself to pull the trigger, but with a peaceful overdose, staring into Nikki's eyes and holding her, and leaves Nikki to wake up covered in her friends' blood, cradling the head of the man who's been raping her.

Nikki's horror in coming back to herself is some of her best acting in the film, the rawness of realising everything she's gone through.

Bear died as he lived: a selfish coward running from the consequences of his actions and abusing the women around him with no thought for how they will feel.

It's a film where the villain is the protagonist and the victim is the source of the horror. It's a really interesting concept, done incredibly well with the camera work, and I can't think of another film that's done it quite like this. The visual framing, with him being scared of her, makes it easy to see her as the source of the horror, but every step of the way is led by Bear and his misogyny and selfishness. The horror, really, is the entitlement of men.

Watch the trailer

Share this review